Learn all about Sherwin-Williams Creamy in this paint color review from the team of color consultants at The Color Concierge.
Sherwin-Williams Creamy is a color that gets talked about a lot, but is one that I haven’t used very much in my paint color consulting projects. To be honest, it always felt too yellow to be a good option for many projects.
But recently, I went to a client’s home for an exterior color consultation and saw that the inside of their home was painted with SW Creamy – and I was blown away. Creamy didn’t look overly yellow: it was gorgeous, muted and (aptly) creamy even in the home’s darker spaces. I still think that the color can be limiting but in the right situation, such as this one it can look fabulous!
I suspect I’ll be using this color more and more in my practice, so today I’m giving you an in-depth review of what can make Sherwin-Williams Creamy (Sample) so pretty.
*This post contains affiliate links for products I use and love. If you click on some links and make a purchase, I will get a small commission at no cost to you. This helps pay for the costs of the blog, so I can continue to offer great content to our readers.
About The Color Concierge
Our Colorado-based paint color consultants make finding the right paint colors for your home easy. Whether you’re painting the exterior or interior of your home, our simple yet effective process lets us get your paint color right the first time. We’ve helped thousands of homeowners transform their homes into a space they love. Learn more about ONLINE COLOR CONSULTATIONS today.
What Color is Sherwin-Williams Creamy?
Sherwin-Williams Creamy is an off-white paint color, but it’s much more saturated with yelloe color than most of the popular off-white hues on the market.
What is the SW Creamy LRV?
Creamy has an LRV of 81, which makes it a pretty light paint color. Despite its high LRV, SW Creamy has enough color to hold its own in very bright and dark rooms.
LRV is short for Light Reflectance Value, which is a measurement of how light (LRV=100) or dark (LRV=0) a color is.
Is Sherwin-Williams Creamy warm or cool?
SW Creamy is definitely a warm paint color. While it’s actually quite muted, it’s warm enough to still make a space feel cozy and sunny.
What are the SW Creamy undertones?
Sherwin-Williams Creamy has very strong yellow undertones. The undertones are so strong, in fact, that I resisted using Creamy for many years as a paint color consultant. I thought it would look too yellow for most projects.
Is Creamy more yellow than Alabaster?
Yes, Creamy has even stronger yellow undertones than Sherwin-Williams Alabaster (Article). While it has an almost identical LRV (Creamy’s LRV is 81 and Alabaster’s LRV is 82), Alabaster is much less saturated with color, so Creamy looks much warmer in place.
Sample SW Creamy
We always recommend that you test paint colors on your home because lighting can change a color completely, both with interiors as well as exteriors.
In the old days, this meant we painted a large poster board with sample pots and a huge mess.
Now we have a better way to test paint, with Samplize Peel-and-Stick samples!
- Samples pre-painted with 2 coats of real paint from the manufacturer.
- Large 9” x 14” samples to see the color better in the lighting.
- Delivered overnight
- Colors are accurate
- Less expensive than painting a large poster board with sample pots
- No mess, and no toxic paint to dispose of
I use these in my color consulting practice for exact results. Discover Samplize peel-and-stick paint samples:
Using Sherwin-Williams Creamy Interior Paint
Sherwin-Williams Creamy is a warm, inviting hue perfect for living rooms, bedrooms, kitchens and more.
Can I use Creamy as an interior trim color?
You could try wrapping an entire room with Sherwin-Williams Creamy, color-drenching (Article) the space and shifting the sheen from walls to ceiling to trim. In this scenario, walls would be painted with an eggshell sheen or similar, trim would be painted with a satin sheen, and the ceiling would be painted with a flat sheen.
In most cases, however, I wouldn’t use Creamy for interior trim. I prefer using a lighter trim color with Creamy walls to provide a bit of contrast. And Creamy is really too yellow to use as interior white trim (Article).
In the client’s home we’re featuring today, their living room is a great example of why I prefer a lighter trim and ceiling paint. While we don’t have color details for the tongue-and-groove ceiling, the lighter hue provides a really lovely contrast with the Creamy walls.
Should I try SW Creamy cabinets?
Sherwin-Willliams Creamy kitchen cabinets could be nice, depending on the countertop and the backsplash that you pair it with. Normally, though, it will look very yellow as a cabinet color. Test carefully!
Creamy could also look gorgeous as white kitchen cabinet (Article) uppers with darker wood, navy or even green lowers in a tuxedo kitchen cabinet color scheme (Article). Don’t use Creamy with beige colors that have pink or peachy undertones because they will look discordant. I’d love to see Creamy with colors like SW Evergreen Fog, SW Link Gray or SW Needlepoint Navy.
Is SW Creamy a good living room paint color?
Absolutely! Our client’s home featured a more formal living room (Article) and a family room painted with SW Creamy and it was absolutely gorgeous. This open-concept space has large windows and is truly the heart of this home, connecting adult and kids’ spaces with the dining room.
SW Creamy walls bring all of these different spaces and uses together, acting as a warm and inviting backdrop for a variety of furniture and decor.
Can I use SW Creamy in a bright room?
Sherwin-Williams Creamy walls are a great option for a bright room. It’s saturated and colorful enough that it won’t reflect green from foliage outside (a common problem for light white and off-white hues).
Lots of natural light also helps neutralize Creamy’s strong yellow undertones, ensuring it doesn’t look too yellow on the wall. A great example of this is this pass-through area of our client’s home, which gets more light than the other areas of this house.
Can I use SW Creamy in a dark room?
One of the best things about SW Creamy is how flexible it is. So while it’s great in a bright room, it looks equally lovely in a darker room, or a room with cool Northern light. This client’s home is located among a lot of trees and has a back porch overhang that blocks from natural light.
But even though the home is fairly dark inside, SW Creamy came through with flying colors. It looked very creamy without looking overly yellow. It really lights up the room without looking dingy.
Is Creamy a good whole-house paint color?
Possibly! SW Creamy may be a bit too yellow for some people’s taste, but it really is a beautiful, flexible off-white paint color. With the right hard finishes, Creamy could absolutely be a whole-house foundational color.
Using Sherwin-Williams Creamy Exterior Paint
Sherwin-Williams Creamy is fairly light for an exterior paint color, because bright sunlight makes colors look 4-5x brighter than they appear indoors. But Creamy’s strong yellow undertones keep it from looking stark or washed out.
It’s not my first choice for an exterior white trim because it’s so yellow, but if you want an all-white exterior color palette Creamy siding could work really well, especially in a home surrounded by trees that lives in the shade. It would end up looking similar to SW Alabaster exterior paint (Article), which you can see on my web designer’s home below. I don’t recommend Creamy as an exterior color for a house that is completely in the bright sunshine. It will look too yellow to be white, and too white to be yellow, if that makes sense.
When should I avoid Creamy?
In a kitchen or bathroom, avoid using Creamy paint with Carrara marble, which is too cool/blue and could look discordant. Also avoid pairing with SW Extra White as a trim and ceiling color.
Don’t use with colors that have strong pink or peachy undertones such as SW Natural Linen. Pink beiges are discordand with yellow beiges and colors that have strong yellow undertones. It also looks terrible paired with taupe colors such as Egret White or Tony Taupe. Avoid pairing with SW Snowbound, which has strong pinkish-taupish undertones.
Avoid use as a trim and ceiling color, because although the LRV is high, it has alot of chroma that will compete with the wall colors… too much yellow!
Creamy also looks best with other muted paint colors, so I’d avoid pairing it with hues that are overly bright and saturated.
The Best SW Creamy Coordinating Colors
SW Creamy looks gorgeous paired with other warm colors and hard finishes, like brass fixtures, matte black accents, bronze and natural wood floors.
Does SW Creamy go with white?
Yes, SW Creamy looks really pretty paired with other white and off-white hues, as long as they don’t have pink or taupe undertones like SW Origami or SW Snowbound. The owner of today’s featured home really likes the white-on-white look and has layered many white colors throughout the family room.
In the picture below, for example, you can see how gorgeous the SW Creamy walls look alongside the white fireplace surround and mantle, white curtains, white chair and white tongue-and-groove ceiling.
For trim and ceiling colors, consider SW Pure White or SW White Snow.
Does SW Creamy go with wood?
Pairing Creamy wall paint with wood floors and other wood tones is one of my favorite combinations. The warm color looks lovely with the wood floors throughout this client’s home. And the cognac leather chair in the family room brings in similar tones and looks beautiful in this space.
Does SW Creamy go with blue?
Yes! Creamy works really well with blue colors, especially muted warm blues. The family room sofa is a great example of this. The blue-gray hue offers a cool balance to the Creamy walls and really brings the space together.
What are the Best Trim and Ceiling Colors For Sherwin-Williams Creamy?
I prefer to use a ceiling and trim color that is lighter than SW Creamy, to provide a bit of contrast. Sherwin-Williams Pure White (Article) would be my top choice for interior trim (Satin) and ceilings (Flat) with Creamy walls. It’s light enough to add contrast but still provides enough warmth to not look stark or discordant. I would also love White Snow as a trim color.
As mentioned before (and I feel strongly about this), avoid SW Origami White, SW Zurich White, and especially SW Snowbound when paired with Creamy.
The Best Sherwin-Williams Creamy Alternatives
Not sure if Creamy is the right color for your project? See how it compares to other popular off-white paint colors.
Sherwin-Williams Creamy vs Sherwin-Williams Alabaster
SW Creamy and SW Alabaster (Article) have nearly identical LRVs but look surprisingly different in place. Creamy is much more saturated with stronger yellow undertones, so it looks even warmer than Alabaster on the wall. Alabaster is more muted, and truly a better all-around color.
Sherwin-Williams Creamy vs Sherwin-Williams Shoji White
Sherwin-Williams Shoji White (Article) is darker and earthier than Creamy. Shoji White has an LRV of 74 and while it has warm undertones, they are green rather than white. This makes Shoji White lean more toward beige than off-white.
Sherwin-Williams Creamy vs Sherwin-Williams Dover White
Sherwin-Williams Dover White is even warmer and creamier than SW Creamy. It has very strong yellow undertones and an LRV of 83, so it’s a bit lighter than Creamy.
Sherwin-Williams Creamy vs Sherwin-Williams Neutral Ground
SW Neutral Ground (Article) is much darker than SW Creamy, with an LRV of 70. Neutral Ground has subtle green undertones, which keep it looking warm in place. I would consider Neutral Ground more of a very light beige than an off-white.
Sherwin-Williams Creamy vs Sherwin-Williams Greek Villa
Sherwin-Williams Greek Villa (Article) is another similar warm white paint color. It’s lighter than Creamy, with an LRV of 84. Although Greek Villa actually appears a bit warmer than Creamy below, in person it looks cleaner and more white than Creamy.
Key Learning Points
Sherwin-Williams Creamy is a warm, saturated off-white paint color perfect for living rooms, kitchens and open-concept spaces.
- Creamy’s strong yellow undertones help it stay saturated even in dark rooms, but don’t look overly yellow in bright spaces.
- Creamy pairs well with some white and off-white hues, as well as natural wood tones and warm blues and greens.
- Sherwin-Williams Creamy exterior paint can work well as a bright white siding color when a home is in the shade, with its warm undertones cutting through the shade to make the house look warm and bright.
Remember: NEVER, EVER use paint matches from a different brand than the one specified. Results are poor and there are no standards for the sheens. Even though your painter may truly believe it can be done, don’t do it. See results from paint matching here.
No matter what, always test your paint colors. It’s a standard best practice. Whenever I test my paint colors, they are perfect, and when I don’t test they turn out wrong. Learn how to test your paint colors here.
Online Color Consulting
Still need help picking the best paint colors? Discover our Online Color Consulting Package.
Related Posts
- Sherwin-Williams Shoji White Paint Color Review
- Sherwin-Williams Alabaster Paint Color Review
- The Best Sherwin-Williams White Paint Colors
- Best White Kitchen Cabinet Paint Colors
About the Author
Hi, I’m Michelle Marceny, founder, owner, and Principal Color Designer at The Color Concierge. I believe a fresh coat of paint can completely transform a space. The Color Concierge was born out of my drive to help clients fall back in love with their homes. My clients trust me to help them find the perfect paint color for their home – whether it’s a whole-house paint color scheme or ideas for a single room.
Since The Color Concierge was founded in 2017, we have completed over 3000 color consultations, both online and in-person. I am a Certified Color Expert with 7 years of experience creating interior and exterior color palettes throughout North America.
We love your comments! Please note that the blog is meant as general advice, and it is not possible to give out specific answers to your paint questions. If you want more specific advice, please consider purchasing a color consultation. Thank you for your understanding.
