6 Best Neutral Paint Colors to Sell Your House

Nothing updates a home to sell like neutral paint colors. If done well, new paint colors can deliver the biggest bang for your buck than any other renovation. But what are the best neutral paint colors to sell a house?

That’s where this article comes in. We just prepared our home for sale, and it looks amazing. As with other sellers we had a couple of rooms that needed some TLC. 

Getting ready to sell your own home? Keep reading for answers to common paint color questions and get our top picks for the best neutral paint colors for the whole house.

Does Paint Color Matter When Selling A House?

Yes, it really does. While it may not seem like that big of a deal, paint color can truly make or break a home sale (and even impact the overall value of your home!). There’s a reason that realtors and paint color consultants recommend specific paint colors to sell a house – it works!

Not only does a fresh coat of paint cover up any imperfections or years of wear and tear – making the space feel newer – the color itself can even help prospective buyers picture themselves making your house a home. There’s no better way to make a sale!

So, how do you paint your house to sell? Let’s explore some common questions we get from our color consulting clients.

Should you paint the interior of your  whole house white?

This is a great question. After all, it would seem that white paint is the perfect blank canvas for new owners. And if you’ve spent any time on Pinterest then you know that all-white walls and even entire homes are definitely still a trend. But is white one of the best neutral paint colors to sell a house? Maybe.

As you probably already know, there’s no such thing as just white paint. Even the most basic of colors come with tons of options! From White Dove to Chantilly Lace and Oxford White to White Heron, choosing a white paint color for your whole house takes time.

You should only use white paint in a sunny space. Using bright white paint in a poorly lit space will make the room look gray and dirty thanks to shadows. There are some good white paints for dark rooms, but they need to be chosen carefully.

If you do decide to paint your home white to sell, be sure to research the best paint sheens for walls, trims and ceilings to add depth and dimension.

Which is better: gray vs beige walls?

We definitely see warmer colors trending, but ultimately you need to pick the colors that look best in your home.

There’s no simple answer for whether gray neutral paint is better than beige neutral paint for selling a house (or vice versa). Instead, deciding between gray paint colors and beige or tan paint colors should really come down to the existing finishes in your home, your lighting and the furniture and art that will be part of staging the home.

Remember: it’s not just the paint color on the walls that sells a house – it’s how that paint comes to life within your home.

Classic fireplace mantle with white tile
Photo by J. Maynard

How to Pick Neutral Paint Colors That Sell a House

Most homeowners paint interiors by room or space over time. This often results in a kaleidoscope of colors that made sense in the moment but doesn’t always match when it comes time to sell.

If you need to paint your home to sell, it’s ideal to paint all the rooms with one color or a planned unified color palette. A simple but effective strategy is to paint the common areas with one neutral and secondary rooms with other neutrals where needed. Learn how to pick white paint colors here.

To save money, use paint colors that you already have in your house, and build on the palette. Coordinate with hard surfaces such as countertops, tile floors, and fireplace stone. You may love it so much you don’t want to move.

Other Home Design Tips To Sell

It’s not only paint color that sells a house! The overall design of your home and the way it is presented to prospective buyers is key. Use these tips to prepare your home for sale – then keep reading for our favorite neutral paint colors.

Hire a Pro Stager to Sell

Staging your house to sell is completely different than decorating. Hire a professional stager to make your home look great in pictures and in person. The home was staged by Heidi Garthwaite with Property Staging and Design.

Invest in a Real Estate Photographer

Real Estate photos are just as critical in today’s online market. Most home searches start online, and in our area (Boulder, CO) realtors usually invest in professional photography. Our realtor, Tim Goodacre, with Goodacre and Company engaged Jamie Maynard, an architectural photographer with Magic Factor Media, to take photos and videos of our house for sale.

6 Best Neutral Paint Colors to Sell A House

Stonington Gray (HC-170)

Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray is one of my all-time favorites.  It is a cool gray with blue undertones, and it looks different in every room.  We painted the common areas, the master bedroom, and two of the bathrooms with Stonington Gray, in eggshell. The trim was Chantilly Lace in Satin sheen.

Check out how the fireplace matches the accent wall and ceiling (Millstone Gray, BM 1581).  This was already in place and didn’t need to be updated. Learn more about Accent Walls here.

Entry and dining room with stonington gray walls and Millstone Gray Accents
Stonington Gray Walls, Millstone Gray Accents / Photo by J. Maynard

We picked Stonington Gray for this space because it complemented the Carrara Marble in the kitchen and the dark green-gray Vermont Slate on the hearth. You can learn more about kitchen finishes here.

classic and timeless kitchen with tuxedo cabinets and lower blue cabinets
Photo by J. Maynard

This living room with south-facing windows is so pretty.  Open concept spaces are alive and well!

Living room with vermont slate hearth and stonington gray walls
Stonington Gray walls, Chantilly Lace trim / Photo by J. Maynard

The basement family room was also painted with Stonington Gray, but it looks a little more blue because of the light.  Check out our secret bookcase door into the Utility Room.  We call it the Bat Cave!

Basement living room with stonington gray walls and secret bookshelf door
Stonington Gray walls, Chantilly Lace Trim / Photo by J. Maynard

The upstairs hallway is also Stonington Gray.  it’s still a gorgeous backdrop for a couple of the rooms that we painted different neutrals.  In a previous renovation, we picked this silver-gray carpet to tie in with the Stonington Gray paint color.

Landing with Gray walls and white stair railings
Stonington Gray walls, Chantilly Lace trim / Photo by J. Maynard

The master bedroom is flooded with west and south-facing exposures and an amazing mountain view.  This is still Stonington Gray with Chantilly Lace trim, but it looks lighter because of all the light.

Master Bedroom with view and stonington gray walls
Stonington Gray Walls, Chantilly Lace trim / Photo by J. Maynard

This South facing bedroom is also painted with Stonington Gray.  It looks absolutely blue, in a wonderful lovely way. This is one reason that Stonington Gray is one of the best neutral paint colors to sell a house: it is so versatile and looks completely different in different lights.

Bedroom with Stonington Gray walls.
Stonington Gray walls / Photo by J. Maynard

This bathroom was also painted Stonington Gray – both walls and ceilings.  I love to paint bathroom walls and ceilings the same color when I’m working with light neutrals.  The ceilings usually look much lighter and its a nice unified touch. This vanity was painted with Benjamin Moore Witching Hour (2128-20). A perfect combination with the blue undertones of Stonington Gray.

A bathroom with Stonington Gray walls and Witching Hour painted bathroom vanity
Stonington Gray Walls and Witching Hour Vanity / Photo by J Maynard

As part of this project, I decided to paint the laundry room walls Chantilly Lace for a nice clean neutral.  The cabinets were already painted Chantilly Lace.  The room looked like an explosion of primer, way too harsh.  I didn’t want to repaint the whole room, so I added Stonington Gray as an accent wall to tie in with the living room.

laundry room with chantilly lace and stonington gray walls
Chantilly Lace walls with Stonington Gray Accent Wall / Photo by J. Maynard

Pale Oak (OC-20)

Pale Oak is one of my favorite neutrals of all time.  It is a light taupe with warm gray undertones. This color is beautiful with just about any interior. It’s definitely high on the list of the best neutral paint colors to sell a house. 

Once again we painted the walls and ceiling the same color, even through the ceiling looks white.

If you need more inspiration for Pale Oak paint, be sure to read our full color review on this beautiful neutral paint color.

Master bath with pale oak walls and ceiling
Pale Oak walls and ceiling / Photo by J. Maynard

Rockport Gray (BM HC-105)

I don’t consider Benjamin Moore Rockport Gray one of the usual neutrals because its a little bit light, but I thought we would throw it in since it is so pretty.  This room didn’t need re-painting, so we left it the way it was.

Bedroom with Rockport Gray walls and Chantilly Lace trim
Rockport Gray Walls – Photo by J. Maynard

We still made sure that it flowed well with the Stonington Gray hallway. So pretty!

A hallway painted with Stonington Gray paint
Photo by J. Maynard

The ensuite bathroom had pink beige tiles from the original build. We painted the bathroom walls Chantilly Lace, a perfect clean white to cool down the tile color. The Chantilly Lace ties in with other white elements in the room.   In a previous remodel we painted the yellowed oak vanity Rockport Gray to match the walls of the room.  It is so pretty!

A bathroom painted with Chantilly Lace and a Rockport Gray vanity
Chantilly Lace walls and ceiling, Rockport Gray vanity / Photo by J. Maynard

Classic Gray (OC-23)

This East facing bedroom had a dramatic transformation..  We decided to paint both walls and ceiling Benjamin Moore Classic Gray to emphasize the beautiful architecture.  It may seem counterintuitive, but it looked so much better than before.  Classic Gray is one of my go-to light neutrals.  It goes with just about anything, making it one of the best paint colors to sell a house.

Bedroom with Classic Gray walls
Classic Gray walls and ceiling / Photo by J. Maynard

Manchester Tan (HC-81)

Benjamin Moore Manchester Tan is a perfect color to update an interior with dated Tuscan finishes. It is a beige with subtle green undertones, and matches just about everything. I have a cousin that only paints her house with Manchester Tan!  In this case, it tied in with the furniture and Zen motif.

Basement bedroom with manchester tan and bamboo window well
Manchester Tan walls / Photo by J. Maynard

Abalone (2108-60)

Benjamin Moore Abalone is a quiet gray with violet undertones. While purple undertones may not seem like the best option for paint colors when selling a house, I love to use this color for a girls room. This color is sometimes even great for a whole house if it matches your kitchen countertops, backsplash tile or your fireplace stone.

Girls basement bedroom with Abalone paint color and bamboo window well
Abalone / Photo by J. Maynard

Stone Hearth (BM 989)

Benjamin Moore Stone Hearth is a mid-toned taupe color, perfect for this powder room.  Learn more about this Powder Room update here. This is a slightly darker and bolder tan than some of the others listed, but is still neutral enough to work as a whole house paint color when selling.

A bathroom painted with Stone Hearth tan paint
Stone Hearth / Photo by J. Maynard
6 best neutral paint colors to sell your home

Best Exterior Paint Colors to Sell Your House – Extra Credit!

In most cases, sellers don’t repaint their exteriors due to cost.  For a small price, you can make your exterior look fresh and new by power washing the home. If your paint colors already look good and the paint job is in good shape, its probably not worth it to repaint.

White Exterior Color Schemes to Sell

Right now, a farmhouse white house with black accents are the biggest trend.  If you need to paint your house, this could be a good option.  Link here to learn about more white paint color schemes. This article shows more details about Farmhouse exterior white paint colors.

A black and white farmhouse exterior

Gray Exterior Color Schemes to Sell

Gray houses and are also on-trend, and a safe choice to update your home for sale. This beautiful gray house is crisp and welcoming. 

A gray and dark gray home exterior with red door

A well done color scheme is always a great choice for sale. In our case, rich exterior paint colors kept our home looking fresh and new for years. Paint colors are Benjamin Moore Ashwood Moss (1484) for the Primary Siding, Tulsa Twilight (2070-10) for the secondary color and Swiss Coffee (OC-45) for the trim.

Learn more about how to pick exterior paint colors here.

purple and green paint color exterior
Aerial photo by J. Maynard

The Verdict

Paint your home with neutral paint colors to sell throughout the whole house.  Use a planned color palette, based on colors that you already have in your house to minimize the cost. Hire a stager to pull it all together, and make sure your realtor hires a professional photographer. ALWAYS test your paint colors like a pro for best results.

Online Color Consulting

If you still need help with paint colors, check out our Online Color Consulting packages or an In-Person Color Consultation in the Denver Metro area.

Online Color Consulting

If you liked this post, don’t forget to pin!

6 best neutral paint colors to sell your home

Test Paint Colors Like a Pro

Our 5 Benjamin Moore Whites… and how to use them

Quick and Easy Laundry Room Makeover

Powder Room Remodel on a Budget

6 Exterior Paint Color Combos – and how to pick them

14 Responses

    1. Hi Noni,
      Revere Pewter is a great color, for sure, and should be considered! We didn’t include it in this project because we chose Classic Gray. Classic Gray is a lighter version of Revere Pewter in the same color family – grey with subtle green undertones.
      MICHELLE

  1. Gorgeous! Do you happen to know what kind of hardwood floors those are? I have stonington gray walls throughout my house (favorite color of all time) and we are trying to find a nice hardwood floor to compliment it. The floor in that house is peeerrrfect. It warms it up so nicely and isn’t too dark. Love it!

    1. Hi Dianna,
      The floors in this house are really beautiful, and they glow in the morning light. They are old-school wood floors with #1 red oak. The stain was 50/50 Classic Gray and Jacobean (Minwax). Also, they were waterpopped. A lovely finish!

      Always make sure to test your stains before you try them. These floors were in Colorado, where the humidity can be as low as 8% in the winter, so they will react differently from a floor in New York with higher humidity.

      Michelle

    1. Either color could lovely with SW Alabaster trim, depending on your lighting and furniture. Just make sure to test the colors on the walls before you paint.
      Michelle

  2. I see that you picked BM Stone Hearth as one of your colors and you have it paired with green on the floor and grays in the powder room. I read on a couple blogs that this color is hard to pair with green because it has a pinky undertone and looks best with brown. Can you explain or give me your comments?
    I have a special interest in it because I just had my family room painted with Stone Hearth and have a Carrera marble fireplace, countertops and a dark green sofa that I planned on using. Help!

    1. Hi Lynn,
      Stone Hearth (984) is the color that we used for the powder room. It is actually a mid-toned taupe color. It’s often mixed up with Stone House (1039), which is a beige with pink undertones. In this case, we matched the taupe to the undertones in the countertop, but A beige with pink undertones such as Stone House probably would have worked too. I just preferred the cooler tones of the taupe color. Taupe can be very lovely with blues or greens. Its hard for me to really evaluate without seeing the room, but my sense is that your finishes it might look really nice with the taupe Stone Hearth.
      Michelle

  3. Hi. Do you remember what kind of carpet that is? We are going to need to update before we move and like that look a lot

    1. Hi Aimee,
      This was a Karastan carpet that is no longer being made. It was purchased at Carpet Exchange.
      Thanks,
      Michelle

  4. What color are the vanities in powder room? What is a good accent color to use with Stone Hearth? I tried different blues and have not found the right one

    1. Hi Susie,
      The vanity in the powder room was Benjamin Moore Onyx (black). There are so many colors that would work well as an accent for Stone Hearth. The best way to find a good color is to repeat a color in a piece of decor or art in the room. Also, stay away from yellow or beige with yellow undertones.
      Thanks,
      Michelle

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Meet Michelle

Driven to help clients fall back in love with their homes with intentional paint color schemes. She started the company based on her passion for color and its ability to make a house a home.

Search the Blog

FREE GUIDE:
8 Easy Ways to Pick Paint Colors